{
  "schema_version": 1,
  "verdict": "PASS",
  "reviewer": "Independent publication reviewer",
  "observed_at": "2026-10-14T03:11:40.037Z",
  "source_file": "decision-gate.mjs",
  "source_sha256": "2973979b18aeca62e08f72872dfcca9bd0ff84478e539e32ee97d9a280d946db",
  "execution": "The reviewer copied the public script into a separate disposable directory and executed that copy.",
  "command": "node --openssl-config=/dev/null decision-gate.mjs",
  "runtime": "v26.5.0",
  "exit_code": 0,
  "cases_passed": 17,
  "assertions_passed": 22,
  "source_comparison": {
    "decision_logic_unchanged": true,
    "only_change": "The original report.command string is replaced by the portable string node decision-gate.mjs."
  },
  "counterexample": {
    "selected_choice": "page_team",
    "probabilities": { "inspect_read_only": 0.9, "stop": 0.1 },
    "broken_gate_action": "page_team",
    "checked_gate_action": "handoff"
  },
  "findings": [
    "The public source produces the stated 17 case results and 22 successful assertions.",
    "The checked adapter does not borrow another choice's probability when the selected key is missing.",
    "The read-only policy fallback retains the original selectedChoice and selectedChoiceProbability metadata."
  ],
  "scope": "Local, synthetic three-field projection and illustrative policy checks only; the script returns records without dispatching tools.",
  "limitations": [
    "No TypeSafe provider call, cloud job, deployed incident application, CodeRabbit reproduction or remote execution occurred.",
    "No model quality, calibration, safety threshold, latency, throughput or adoption metric was measured.",
    "The test does not validate confidence or the full HTTP envelope, authenticate principals, verify object ownership or expiry, bind dynamic question state, or implement a real executor.",
    "NaN and Infinity are in-memory defensive fixtures, not observed provider JSON."
  ]
}